Manager Ronnie Moore was seething after seeing Rotherham concede a last-gasp equaliser to draw 1-1 with Hereford at Don Valley Stadium.
The Millers missed a hatful of first-half chances and then conceded a goal in the last minute to throw away the lead Adam Le Fondre had given them in the 11th minute.
"We should have been out of sight. How we weren't four up at half-time is beyond me," said Moore.
"We had so many chances in the game, but I've seen it all before. You've got to take your chances when they come, but we got done in the last minute from a nothing ball into the area.
"No disrespect to Hereford, but we should be burying teams like that here. We were like pussy cats in both boxes."
He added: "It is frustrating. It's great that we are creating, but when you are not converting you have to be rock solid and one of our centre-halves made a wrong decision and we were punished."
Copyright (c) PA Sport 2009, All Rights Reserved.