The Manchester clubs, once again, ended up the top two in the Premier League in 2012/13, however when combining a Manchester XI against an XI from London, which team would come out on top?

Here we take an unbiased look at whether the Premier League's Manchester rivals - City and United - would come out on top against the best players from Chelsea, Arsenal, Tottenham Hotspur and Fulham. 

Using data from EA Sports' Player Performance Index (PPI) from last season and a pair of star squads selected by talkSPORT, GMS has come up with a definitive guide as to which players could propel their respective cities to success in such a derby. 


Goalkeepers: David de Gea (Man Utd) vs. Petr Cech (Chelsea)
PPI outcome - De Gea: 441 vs. Cech: 501 (LONDON wins)

Right-back: Gael Clichy (Man City) vs. Cesar Azpilicueta (Chelsea)
PPI outcome - Clichy: 401 vs. Azpilicueta: 375 (MANCHESTER wins)

Centre-back: Vincent Kompany (Man City) vs. Laurent Koscielny (Arsenal)
PPI outcome - Kompany: 316 vs. Koscielny: 285 (MANCHESTER wins)

Centre-back: Rio Ferdinand (Man Utd) vs. Jan Vertonghen (Tottenham Hotspur)
PPI outcome - Ferdinand: 432 vs. Vertonghen: 467 (LONDON wins)

Left-back: Pablo Zabaleta (Man City) vs. Ashley Cole (Chelsea)
PPI outcome - Zabaleta: 436 vs. Cole: 419 (MANCHESTER wins)

Right-midfield: Shinji Kagawa (Man Utd) vs. Eden Hazard (Chelsea)
PPI outcome - Kagawa: 295 vs. Hazard: 614 (LONDON wins)

Centre-midfield: Yaya Toure (Man City) vs. David Luiz (Chelsea)
PPI outcome - Toure: 564 vs. Luiz: 382 (MANCHESTER wins)

Centre-midfield: Michael Carrick (Man Utd) vs. Frank Lampard (Chelsea)
PPI outcome - Carrick: 558 vs. Lampard: 448 (MANCHESTER wins)

Left-midfield: David Silva (Man City) vs. Gareth Bale (Tottenham Hotspur)
PPI outcome - Silva: 552 vs. Bale: 705 (LONDON wins)

Centre-forward: Sergio Aguero (Man City) vs. Juan Mata (Chelsea)
PPI outcome - Aguero: 392 vs. Mata: 706 (LONDON wins)

Striker: Robin van Persie (Man Utd) vs. Dimitar Berbatov (Fulham)
PPI outcome - Van Persie: 827 vs. Berbatov: 530 (MANCHESTER WINS) 

So, after a theoretical extra time and perhaps even penalty shoot-out, the Manchester XI would secure victory over their London rivals, by six players to five.

The back four and goalkeeper is made up of a mix from Manchester and London - the Manchester partnership of Yaya Toure and Michael Carrick prove the best central midfield pairing, whilst Eden Hazard and Gareth Bale would combine to make a world-class winger duo, ahead of Shinji Kagawa and David Silva.

Statistically, Robin van Persie is the best player to be taking part in the hypothetical match-up, after leading United to their twentieth Premier League title.


Write for GiveMeSport! Sign-up to the GMS Writing Academy here:

DISCLAIMER: This article has been written by a member of the GiveMeSport Writing Academy and does not represent the views of or SportsNewMedia. The views and opinions expressed are solely that of the author credited at the top of this article. and SportsNewMedia do not take any responsibility for the content of its contributors.

Do YOU want to write for GiveMeSport? Get started today by signing-up and submitting an article HERE: