When the Streak ended - the overwhelming 21-0 at WrestleMania, the WWE's top dog - the Undertaker's coveted streak - wrestling fans around the world were aghast.
Bigger Stars had fallen trying to end the unbeaten run... all had fallen trying to end it.
But such is Vince McMahon's infatuation with Brock Lesnar that he made one of his most coveted asset lose a major spark, just to push Lesnar further.
SIGN UP NOW
Want to become a GMS writer? Sign up now and submit a 250 word test article: http://gms.to/haveyoursay4
However, this debate could rage on forever.
For now, what seems more baffling is that WWE is reigniting the feud.
The Undertaker wants revenge against the next Big Thing.
All theorists sit confused now. Would the WWE risk making Lesnar lose against the Deadman: a war machine, an unbeatable beast, a proven UFC Champ, going down against an aged wrestler.
Or do they let the Deadman lose again, effectively crumbling Taker's aura so close to his retirement?
Here's five possible outcomes we could expect from their showdown at Survivor Series