The Republic of Ireland international signed from Crystal Palace 12 months ago, but he played less than 750 minutes in all competitions during his first campaign at the club.
What’s the latest news involving McCarthy?
Following 11 years in the Premier League, the midfielder opted to make the move north of the border after his deal at Selhurst Park had expired.
According to the Daily Record, the Glasgow-born star is a boyhood Hoops fan, highlighting why he snapped up the chance to sign for the Scottish giants.
As a result, the 31-year-old featured just 22 times in all competitions and while he collected a Scottish Premiership and League Cup medal, he was restricted to just four starts in the top-flight and only two from October onwards.
What did Joseph say about McCarthy?
He told GIVEMESPORT: “James McCarthy hasn’t really worked out as maybe he would have hoped and when you watch him play you don’t really see where he fits in to the way that Ange Postecoglou plays.
“He slows the game down a lot, he seemed quite off the pace in a lot of the games that he came on in, although that happens if you’re playing regularly and not match fit.”
Darwin Nunez to Liverpool! Done Deal! Hear more on The Football Terrace…
Should McCarthy stay at Celtic?
When the experienced midfielder made the move to Celtic, he penned a four-year deal with the club he supported as a boy.
But less than 12 months into his Hoops career, it already feels extremely unlikely that McCarthy will see out the duration of his contract.
The departures of Tom Rogic and Nir Bitton should help McCarthy’s case for more regular game-time, though, plus the fact that Celtic are in the Champions League, but he’ll still be competing against the likes of Callum McGregor, Reo Hatate, Matt O’Riley and Ross Turnbull for a starting place.
McCarthy should also benefit from a full pre-season, having joined when the season had already got underway, so it might be worth the ex-Wigan ace seeing how things pan out and then revaluating his situation in January before making any hasty decisions in the meantime.